Matt Smith

Smith was cast as the Eleventh Doctor in the British science-fiction television series Doctor Who in late 2008, to replace David Tennant, who announced his departure in October 2008. Smith was a relatively unknown actor compared to the actors speculated to take on the role, who included Paterson Joseph, David Morrissey, Sean Pertwee, James Nesbitt, Russell Tovey, Catherine Zeta Jones, Chiwetel Ejiofor, and Billie Piper. Smith was first named as a possible successor less than a day before he was announced as the Eleventh Doctor, on the 3 January 2009 edition of BBC Breakfast among the speculated names. His obscurity prompted the news headline “Doctor Who?”, a pun on the show’s title.

Smith was one of the earliest actors to audition for the role, performing on the first day. The production team, consisting of the incoming showrunner, Steven Moffat, and BBC Wales Head of Drama and executive producer, Piers Wenger, immediately singled him out based on his performance. At 26 years old, Smith is three years younger than Peter Davison was at the time of his casting as the Doctor in 1981, and younger than any other actor suggested for the role. After three weeks of auditions, Moffat and Wenger agreed that it had “always been Matt” and approached him to accept the role. The BBC were cautious about casting him because they felt that a 26-year-old could not play the Doctor adequately; Wenger shared the same sentiment, but noted that Smith had proven his acting quality in Party Animals, which Wenger thought highlighted Smith’s “mercurial qualities”. The casting was controversial among fans: some believed that Smith was inexperienced and too young for the role while others supported his acting ability.